Issue No.457
12 Jul, 2003

Hong Kong Professional Teachers' Union

Diversified Training of language teachers is needed

James Hon 

The Standing Committee on Language Education and Research (SCOLAR) has issued its final report of the language education review. Although there are always rooms for a better policy, the report contains some good suggestions. Chapter Four of the Report talks about the ways to ehance the qualifications of language teachers. This is worthy of further discussions.

In principle, it is good to upgrade the quailifications of a new language teacher to at least a Bachelor of Education majoring relevant language subjects or a relevant language degree with a relevant Post-Graduate Diploma of Education. In the past, because of the fact that most of the English graduates were attracted to the commercial sector or the civil service, many English teachers in Hong Kong did not major in English. It will be a good opportunity to recruit more English trained graduates to join the profession in a period of recession. More importantly, SCOLAR does not under-estimate the necessity of professional training and emphasizes that even the English graduates should further pursue teacher training so that they can possess, besides the subject matter of the language, the skills and knowledge base to teach.

However, it is also a big question for the teacher training insitutes to tailor-make their courses for these new comers of the profession. Courses of Education theories and teaching skills have to be re-designed and concentrated. What the SCOLAR demands is really a challenge. Thus it should be welcome that the implementation of this new requirement is postponed to 2004-2005 as the course providers does not need to rush for the course development.

For the benefits of students in general, all teachers should be professionally trained. And education theories, teaching skills and commitment of a teacher should be well balanced and guaranteed in the training courses. Pre-service training and in-service development, instead of the so-called benchmarking, are the best ways to enhance teacher professionalism.

As for the in-service training, SCOLAR is concerned with the heavy workload of language teachers. After receiving the feedback that most teachers object any deadline for the acquisition of the qualifications required, the authority should take careful steps to avoid the vulgar implementation like that of the benchmarking policy.
The government should give top priority to the design of an appropriate and practical course for serving language teachers. As I have always emphasized, teachers' continuous professional training should be diversified and designed to suit the needs of different stages of a teacher's career. There can never be a single course which is suitable for all teachers. Such a rigid course would undoubtedly waste the time and energy of a teacher and the government funding too. The credit exemption concept suggested by SCOLAR may pave the way for diversified training courses. We welcome the concept and expect that the courses provided would meet the practical needs of the teachers.

The basic philosophy of language benchmarking is teacher deificiency and denies the existing teacher qualifications. On the contrary, SCOLAR report adopts the model of continuous development. Comparing the two, one can easily find out which is better for teacher development and education improvement. Respect and cooperation, instead of insult and denial, are essential for any education reform. (Translated by Staff)

Date: 9 AUG 2003 ( Sat )
Time: 8:00pm
Venue: HKCEC Hall 3 ( 灣仔會展)

Original Price : HK$580   Special Price : HK$400


Rain , Angela , Light My Fire , Guantanamera , Marley Pure Drive , Old Turkey Buzzard, California Dreaming ,The Windmills Of Your Mind , Always Something There To Remind Me

Ordering Method:

  1. Member can take the order form from HKPTU.
  2. Member should return the order form together with the crossed cheque payable to Hong Kong Professional Teachers' Union to Welfare Dept. (Kowloon Centre of HKPTU)
  3. Member will be notified by telephone for taking the ordered tickets on / before 6 August 2003.
  4. Order subscription will be based on a first-come first-served basis.

For enquiries : Please contact Convey Ltd. Cecil Chung on 21210933

Toshiba Notebook

Acer Notebook
Computer Promotion

Kowloon Centre
Date and Time:
19 July 2003 11:00 -19:00
20 July 2003 11:00 -17:30

Causeway Bay Services Centre
Date and Time:
26 July 2003 11:00 - 19:00
27 July 2003 11:00 - 17:00

TECRA S1 Notebook $ 13380
Intel Centrino / PM 1.5 GHz / 40G HDD / Combo / 15" TFT

Satellite A10 Notebook $ 9288
P4-M 2.0 / 30G HDD / Combo / 15" TFT

Free Gifts: Norman Virus Control Software and Notebook Case

For enquiries:
Please call 29533338 CHEVALIER

Kowloon Centre
Date and Time:
19 July 2003 10:00 - 19:00
20 July 2003 10:30 - 17:30

Acer TravelMate 281XC Notebook $8964**
Mobile Intel Pentium 4 1.8Ghz
14.1" TFT LCD
256MB DDR Ram
8x DVD 24x/10x/24x CD-RW Combo Drive

Acer Veriton 3500G PC $4968**
Intel Pentium 4 2.2Ghz
256MB DDR Ram
40GB ATA-100 HDD
16x DVD 48x/24x/48x CD-RW Combo Drive
* Monitor Excluded

** FREE Gift: Microsoft Office XP OEM
Standard Educational Version
(While stock lasts)

For enquiries:
Please call 28210210 Acer

Place your order at the welfare services counter.
The price listed at the time of order is final and is not affected by any subsequent price fluctuation.
Jumbo Air-conditioner
ASG9ASP 8900BTU $2564
ASG12ASP 11800BTU $3638
Philco Air-conditioner
GP309WSC 9000BTU $2483
GP312WSC 12000BTU $3086
GP318WSC 18000BTU $4392
Carrier Air-conditioner
CHK-07SR 7550BTU $1147
CHK-09SR 9000BTU $1756
CHK-12SR 12000BTU $2244
CHK-18SR 18000BTU $2842
CHK-22SR 22000BTU $3939
42BV8 7100BTU $3289
42BV10 10000BTU $3025
42BV13 12000BTU $4598
42BG18 18000BTU $5309
JNC Digital Voice Recorder
SSF-300(128MB) $1356
SSF-302(256MB) $1596
SSF-11(128MB) $1027
SSF-10(64MB) $866
USB-250 $393
USB-350 $473
Rasonic Refrigerator
RA-FR198 198litre/2doors $1797
RA-FR248 248litre/3doors $2680
RA-FR265 265litre/3doors $2944
Toshiba Refrigerator
GR-N32HT 280litre/2doors $3097
GR-N35HTV 305litre/3doors $3746
GR-N37HT 320litre/2doors $3746
Sakura Stove
SG-L880S/Petroleum Gas $675
SG-T880F/Gas $725
SG-T880S/Gas $675
The price listed at the time of order is final and is not affected by any subsequent price fluctuation.
Hong Kong Professional Teachers'nion(HKPTU) and The Bank of East Asia are pleased to introduce the HKPTU VISA Card?.
Continuous Annual Fee Waiver
HKPTU VISA CARD ACCEPTANCE FORM will be available at Hong Kong
Professional Teachers' Union Kowloon Office, Causeway Bay Service Center and all branches of The Bank of East Asia.

For any enquiries, please call the Bank's Credit Card Customer
Services Hotline at 2838 2283

Apply Now!

Upon successful application of "HKPTU VISA Card"
on or before 31 December, 2003, one of the following


Cordless Wet & Dry Vacuum Cleaner or 3-in-1 Steam, Grill & Sandwich Maker

*Accumlated retail spending or cash advance of
HK $1,500 or above within 2 months.