PTU News Reporter
Prof Tsui Lap-chee served as vice chancellor of the Hong Kong University (HKU) for 12 years, which ended on 1 April. Before the end of his tenure, he talked and exchanged views with Fung Wai-wah, our President, about the universities’ over-emphasis on the university rankings, the admission of too many non-local students, the undermining of academic freedom, and other hot issues concerned by our tertiary institutions.
Emphasis on the University Rankings at cost of the community and teaching quality
According to Fung, fierce competitions among local and international institutions were attributed to the emphasis on the university rankings, and as a result the local institutions tended towards distributing excessive resources to the research projects, which led to the eclipse of teaching and in turn deteriorated the teaching quality. Tsui responded that the university rankings system has been adopting for many years in the US, and the ranking criteria did not only cover the number of journal papers published. “Tertiary education should aim at achieving these 3 main objectives: create knowledge, serve the community, and nurture students. Disappointingly, in the rankings system the latter two criteria are less assessed,” said Tsui. He also admitted that the rankings system would create tensions for the institutions, but it would enhance schools proactivity. HKU had set up her own visions, which did not only focus on local competitions, but were based on a global perspective. Tsui believed that students’ global perspectives, care for community and ability of critical thinking should be nurtured in the institutions. “The institutions should teach students how to grasp the new knowledge and think critically,” said Tsui.
Fung further pointed that teaching staff of the local institutions was assessed by their number of journal articles published, which led to teachers’ over-emphasis on research projects, rather than stimulating students to learn and think. Tsui agreed that teachers’ performance should be evaluated objectively and from different perspectives. “HKU would now prefer recruiting young scholars to renowned professors, as the former would bring new insights to the institutions, though they might not be able to upgrade our university rankings immediately,” added Tsui. …… 閱讀全文 →